Excision VS Ablation surgery
Share
Ablation and Excision are two different surgical techniques used to treat Endometriosis. Both aim to remove or reduce endometrial tissue growth outside the uterus, but they do so in distinct ways and have different implications for patient outcomes. Here’s a detailed comparison of the two:
Ablation surgery
Procedure:
- Technique: Ablation involves the destruction of endometrial lesions using heat (thermal ablation), laser or electric current (electrocautery).
- Depth: The ablated tissue is superficially destroyed, often only on the surface of the lesions.
Advantages:
- Less invasive: Typically involves a shorter surgery time and may result in less immediate postoperative pain.
- Recovery time: Often associated with a shorter recovery period compared to excision.
Disadvantages:
- Superficial treatment: Ablation does not remove the entire Endometriosis lesion, especially if the lesions are deep. This can leave behind deeper Endometriosis tissue that may continue to cause symptoms.
- Higher recurrence rates: Because the lesions are not fully removed, there is a higher chance of symptom recurrence over time.
- Symptom relief: Some studies suggest that symptom relief from ablation may be less complete and less durable compared to excision.
Excision surgery (Our gold standard in the Endo world)
Procedure:
- Technique: Excision involves cutting out and completely removing endometrial lesions from their roots, including deeper tissue layers.
- Depth: The entire lesion, including its depth, is excised, which is more thorough.
Advantages:
- Thorough removal: Excision removes the entire lesion, including deeper implants, which can lead to more effective and longer-lasting symptom relief.
- Lower recurrence rates: Complete removal of the lesions often results in lower recurrence rates compared to ablation. It's important to know Endometriosis can grow back despite having excision surgery.
- Diagnostic accuracy: Excised tissue can be sent for pathological examination, providing a precise diagnosis.
- Gold standard: Excision surgery is currently our "gold standard" procedure as there is no current cure for Endometriosis.
Disadvantages:
- More invasive: Excision is typically a more complex and longer surgery compared to ablation, which can mean a longer operative time.
- Recovery time: May involve a longer recovery period due to the more extensive nature of the surgery.
- Skill requirement: Requires a higher level of surgical expertise and experience, and it’s important to have the procedure performed by a specialist in Endometriosis.
Choosing between Ablation and Excision
The choice between ablation and excision depends on various factors that is decided between you and your Specialist:
- Severity of Endometriosis:
- Mild cases: Ablation may be sufficient for superficial endometrial implants.
- Moderate to severe cases: Excision is generally preferred for deeper and more extensive disease.
- Symptoms:
- Persistent or severe symptoms: Excision may offer better long-term relief for severe pain or other persistent symptoms.
- Fertility concerns:
- Infertility: Excision may be more beneficial for women with Endometriosis who are trying to conceive, as it more thoroughly removes the lesions that could be affecting fertility.
- Recurrence and long-term management:
- Lower recurrence: Excision is often recommended to reduce the likelihood of symptom recurrence and the need for additional surgeries.
- Surgeon’s expertise:
- Specialist surgeon: The success and outcomes of either procedure can depend significantly on the surgeon’s skill and experience with Endometriosis surgery.
Both ablation and excision surgeries are valuable techniques for managing Endometriosis, but they serve different purposes and have different implications for patient outcomes. Ablation may be suitable for less severe cases and offers a quicker recovery, while Excision is generally more thorough and effective for long-term relief, especially in more severe or deep-seated cases.
Excision surgery is the gold standard for Endometriosis however it’s crucial to discuss these options with a Specialist who can tailor the surgical approach to your specific condition and needs.
PLEASE NOTE: The Endo Essentials company takes no responsibility for your diagnosis, tailoring your treatment/plan, we do not claim to be doctors and strongly recommend seeking medical advice from a Health Physician to treat your symptoms. We write these blogs purely based on the evidence provided at the current time and try our best to keep these blogs as up to date as possible.